KichikujimaFreak Island Edit What would you like to edit? SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links   1nq43

Its so bad i cant stop reading. Its like the author wants to change the genre every few chapters. Oh its a slasher, now its radioactive horror cannibals, now its a war on the island, now all the cast is stuck in a hole eating each other, now its a tsundere romance manga and oh is that the fucking pope i see coming to smite the island with his stand powers. WTF is going on I can't look away! Read this for the same reason you watch The Room or Birdemic not because its good but because its a fucking wild ride.

This story starts off as a cross between "The Hills Have Eyes" and "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre" on an island, then goes in an odd direction: the psychotic, mutant cannibal clan are by far the most sympathetic characters in it. This is probably this manga's most notable feature, and I think it's biggest shortcoming. The intent was likely to be social commentary, as in even decent people will do horrible things in bad enough circumstances. Instead, it largely just comes off as every single character being a cartoonishly horrible person.

The reason I consider this a shortcoming is because, if the insane cannibals are far more ... sympathetic than the people they're hunting, you don't really care if the protagonists live or die and any horror subjected to them is rendered moot. Still, the cannibals' own antics do make the story somewhat entertaining, even if I've mostly been left hoping they'll just kill all the protagonists and be done with it.

TL;DR It's a trainwreck.

Contains minor spoilers from the first ~5 chapters

The story starts out like any Slasher film does: bunch of teens get stranded in the killer's territory and when they realize what's going on, it's already too late. Nothing original, but fine. Can work with that.
But from chapter 2 onwards it just gets more and more unbelievable.
From the very beginning our MC spots several nuclear waste barrels in the surrounding waters, but refuses to tell his friends. Even when they start to get hungry and catch some fish, he does not tell them that these fish are contaminated, but rather lets them ... eat the deformed creatures. One of the bunch gets an infected wound and maggots start to nibble on the necrosis, but again: no one says a thing!
Credibility right out the window, especially when there's the one clichéd crybaby in the group that just nitpicks each and everything.

The art is... inconsistent.
It starts out decent looking. Gorgeous backgrounds, characters are drawn decently and weapons look believable.
But further down, the limbs, especially hands and feet, start looking more and more strange. At times they don't even match the rest of the body, just look deformed, even though storywise they should be intact.
Characters in the background are just an eyesore.

I enjoyed a lot of media which his considered bad or varies in its quality throughout its cycle, but this is just atrocious.
The little enjoyment you could get from the gore is spoiled by unbreakable plot-armor. Got a stone thrown at you so it's stuck in your skull? No problemo, just remove and bandaid it and you're good to go...

So, would I recommend it? Hell, no.

Story - one big cliché
Art - mostly poor
Characters - unlikeable
Enjoyment - non-existent

____

Update after hitting chapter 55:

Skip this, honestly!
It gets worse with every page:
- nonsensical plot twists
- oh, dear lord plot-armor...
- characters actually get more and more flat
- at times, this looks like a grade schoolers first attempt at drawing a human body