Mahou Shoujo SiteMagical Girl Site Edit What would you like to edit? SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links   4z5c1l

Sooo... THIS IS COMPLETE MADNESS, and I wont spoil anything to you, you have to read this manga. If you watched the anime and didnt like it pleeeeease give this a second chance; if you somehow liked the anime or though it was ok you'll like this a lot better; and if you dindt watch the anime just DONT DO IT and read the manga instead (TRUST ME ON THIS ONE).

I read this after watching the anime hopping for another instance of that "so bad its good" kinda feel, but I ended up disappointed. The manga turned out being unironically good (very solid in fact). ... It has some serious flaws of course (witch I'll leave you to discover), but it shows that the people behind it really cared about it, this project is someone's baby. This is the brainchild of some man, and the moment you pick it up, you are in someone else's world, its complete insanity, and I LOVE IT.

So, without further to do, lets check the bulletpoints!

Story: Its all over the place, there is a lot of it, and its all just crazy. It starts with a simple enough premise, but as the plot unfolds it derails into complete and utter rampaging clusterf***. The weird thing is that all of this madness was planned from the very beginning, its twists and turns where all planned beforehand witch make it kinda of impressive than this kinda of madfest were not made as it went on. You can never guess what's coming up next, it really throw your expectations out of the window sometimes because of the "no one would be crazy enough to go THAT way" factor. Its entertaining and imaginative for sure.

Art: I would say its very solid. During the first chapters there are some inconsistencies in the art style, but as the series picks up its all pretty good and consistent.

Character: Here is where the anime fails and the manga succeeded. They had their time to grow! You get to care for them not out of artificially forced pity derived from the initial shock value, but out of having the time to get to know them, you want to see them succeed. That apply specially to our protagonist, Aya really does grow as a character.

Enjoyment: What can I say here? Its just really entertaining! I found myself chanting at the screen a couple of time at certain moments, just of how invested I was. For me, it was a blast.

AWARDS TIME!

-JOJO REFERENCES!
Of course, I spoted a few. They are always welcome.

-SOMEBODY CARED!
This is a work of insanity and ion. Thats something I can respect and enjoy.

And the final award:
-SOMEONE FIX THIS!
I think that if some the flaws are ironed out, this could be a genera breaking masterpiece! There is a lot of creativity and good elements in here, there is more value to be made.

So well, this is it.

Esa fue mi reviu de majó yoyo sait para comodor 64, Y espero que les aya gustado.
Chau!

Mahou shoujo site was an anime I saw 3 years ago or so and I liked it.I didn't think of reading the manga ,because I was like ''A second season might be released'' . A month ago or so , I learnt that the anime changed stuff from the manga so I realised that there'll be no season 2 and I decided to read the manga.

The story was nice,it had an interesting premise.For sure it was edgy like REALLY edgy ,but I enjoyed it ,I guess. A thing I kinda didn't like was the conclusion (2 last chapters) ,in which characters from the mangaka's previous ... manga appeared and somehow a connection between the two series was evoked. What can I say ,maybe people who have read both series actually enjoyed that thing,but it felt off to me.

The art was nice and clean ,which made mahou shoujo site an easy read.

The characters were fine I guess, some of theme were likeable and were surrounded by their own mysteries .I felt that some others could have been managed better though.

Overall I enjoyed the series ,it was a nice read and I would recommend it to people who are into magical girls and edgy series

**spoiler warning**

The idea/concept is really nice, but all the writing is very horrible and overall disgusting.

Who makes the protagonist and love-interest lesbians and fall in love, only 50-100 chapters in to reveal that they are blood-related twins? Are we romanticizing incest now? Is literally everyone just ignoring that they're twin sisters??

Next is the male characters, I gotta be honest there is no positive male character that isnt disgusting at all. Most of the men are all abusive. Every gay male character was seen as a sexual harasser/rapist. And the only black man in the ENTIRE manga is shown to be a pedophilic gay ... rapist. And the way he's drawn uses racist stereotypes which is not good!!!

The nongay male character, Aya's brother? Sexually abused her. And he was redeemed at the end. Why was he redeemed?? Why are we supposed to sympathize with a sexually abusive brother who apparently has a god complex?

And the boy who had a crush on Aya in the beginning of the manga?? That was her actual blood-related father in disguise!! What! Why would you write that!

The only good thing about this manga was making one of the main characters a transgirl. She's seen as a girl and not a boy. Her best friend genders her correctly and so does her mom. Her mom is accepting and loving. I didnt like that she was used for the "only boys can defeat the King" but she didnt defeat the king as another magical girl used a sex-change magical girl ability to defeat the king.

Shit writing!!! Excessive usage of shock means that the writer hasnt thought out or fleshed out the story good enough, and has to resort to shock value.