The iDOLM@STER Cinderella Girls: U149

Mature grade school student Arisu Tachibana is an aspiring idol who receives an invitation from her company president to participate in the Third Entertainment Section—a new idol project. Arisu and eight other young girls soon meet their producer before beginning idol-related activities.

To the girls' surprise, their producer appears to be a childlike adult and nothing like what they had imagined. The producer, who is taking on the position for the first time, also had no idea that he would be meeting a group of short, young idols. The awkward situation leaves Arisu disappointed, and she wishes for a producer change.

However, the producer, with his genuine love for idols and his desire to see them shine, will not let this opportunity and expresses that he is serious about working with the girls. Thankfully, the young idols accept the producer after seeing his unwavering ion for idols, serving as the start of their journey to the stage of dreams.

[Written by MAL Rewrite]

Tachibana, Arisu Main

Satou, Amina Japanese

Sakurai, Momoka Main

Terui, Haruka Japanese

Ichihara, Nina Main

Kuno, Misaki Japanese

Akagi, Miria Main

Kurosawa, Tomoyo Japanese

Yuuki, Haru Main

Koichi, Makoto Japanese

Matoba, Risa Main

Tamegai, Hana Japanese

Sasaki, Chie Main

Imai, Asaka Japanese

Koga, Koharu Main

Komori, Yuri Japanese

Ryuuzaki, Kaoru Main

Haruse, Natsumi Japanese

Producer Main

Yonai, Yuki Japanese

Kashiwaya, Tomohiro Producer, Executive Producer

Tomita, Kouichirou Producer

Akita, Minoru Producer

Kawaguchi, Ryouta Producer

Reviews

Mar 18, 2024

Asuken

Recommended

If you got to know this anime through the memes, I beseech you to look a little deeper, because this is one of the best directed shows in the past year. And if you're an idol anime or im@s fan, there's plenty of cute girls to root for to warrant a watch.

But firstly, the animation is really good. Considering it's done by Cygames Pictures, whose parent company is a mobile game producer, it was a pleasant surprise. Honestly, it looks better than what A-1 did in the other im@s installments. However, the dance scenes specifically, of which there are only 3, are done with a ... bit of CG. It doesn't look horrible, but I wished they took a page out of A-1's book and did it completely hand-drawn.

The anime enhances its already great animation with excellent shot compositions. Episode 1 is a good example. The scene with Arisu and the Producer deserves a complete in-depth analysis, but essentially what the show does is play with position and the space each character takes up in shots. It uses a staircase as a metaphor for one's ion for a dream. The Producer is higher up initially and after a typical speech on hopes and aspirations or whatever, Arisu climbs the stairs to him. She had been inspired by the Producer to pursue her dreams, made clear by the rising motion. This isn't just a one-off thing. The metaphor returns with the same context in a later episode and with a twist. It's beautiful storytelling.

It's not just themes that get emphasized though. Through clever visual language, characters feel more real and relatable. The anime is episodic and character-driven; there's no overarching plot or villain. The structure is similar to the other im@s animes, showcasing one main idol per episode, though other girls do get to share the spotlight. I would say the success of the show depends on how well it presents its characters. Unfortunately, with only 12 episodes, it's doubtful anyone would feel attached to every single idol, without first being familiar with them from the games/manga. However, there are definitely a few stand-out characters who you will love. I find the better crafted episodes correlate to the more memorable characters.

And a quick word on the girls: Yes, they're middle-schoolers. Yes, they're cute. But it's actually plot-relevant! It's not an anime featuring 'lolis' for no reason other than to appeal to lolicons. The central theme is the idea of growing up and it can only work because the idols are so young. But if you were attracted to the show because of lolis, you'd still be satisfied I think.

The music is nothing to write home about. The songs aren't as impactful as the main CG songs, much less the 765 ones. I did like the opening and Momoka's song though. To add on, I noticed a little motif in the score with a ticking clock that would play during stressful or pivotal moments that I thought was interesting. Apparently it's from the main CG series, but it just disappears from later episodes, so...

Anyhow, U149 is a fantastic anime. I think it's a good gateway to the idol genre if you're new to it (you don't need to watch the other im@s animes before this one, though if you watched CG you might enjoy it better). However, it also works as an excellent standalone piece with great direction, art and characters.

Reviewer’s Rating: 8

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by Asuken (2)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Dec 17, 2024

anonyymio

Mixed Feelings

Watched this enticed by the memes. I expected some generic cheerful loli/moe with fan service, but was surprised how deep experience this was.

Especially Tatchibana hit hard. Such a young girl burdened by so much responsibility. To me this anime illustrated the darker sides of the Japanese culture. Pressure to perform, corporate hierarchies, using young girls for profit, everything seemingly very sterile, but hiding the pain. The series felt thus very conflicting and absurd to me, as does the whole idol bussiness:

Lone men are marketted imaginary girls that supposedly care about you. - On the other hand, isn't all anime this and I am watching with ... gluttony?

Girls are marketted a specific image which to become, and everything is laced with shining make-up, fashionable outfits, youthful innocence, songs, love and kira kira. On one hand these dreams and desires are sweet, but for most they are some kind of deceptive mirages and spectres, with basically only old men on the top really benefitting from the system and younger using it just to suppress their desires in lack of a real girl.

This in regard, though, apart from Risa's lolicon jokes the anime was not sexualized, except for the one concert with the older girls. There I found myself weirded out by ~ second graders cheering for songs with sexual lyrics (although they did not perform). I personally would have liked more fan service, but this was confusing as it seemed out of place.

Nevertheless, there is also my favourite trope, the wise man on the top who has no further need for competition, but has reached personal growth and wishes to share it.

Finally, I especially disliked Producer-san trying to please everybody, and the implication, that this is the correct way to act usually. Yes, I see my Western individualism rising its head, but his kind of people pleasing leads to growth of neither the pleaser nor the one pleased and pampered.

But anyway, watching the series was a much more painful and deep experience than I had estimated. Raised some philosophical thoughts and issues, which is not bad. But next I want to watch some CGDCT without consumerism, such as Non non biyori.

Reviewer’s Rating: 6

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by anonyymio (1)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Jul 1, 2023

Firechick12012

Not Recommended

Funny

The IdolM@ster series needs no introduction...if you live in Japan. Basically, for the uninitiated, it's a series of video games where you raise and train idols to become famous. It's now a multimedia franchise that continues to rake in money to this very day. If you want for information on the franchise as a whole, I recommend the Project Im@s wiki, as it pretty much has everything you could ever need, from game info to translations of all the songs and their lyrics. I haven't seen any of the anime that were made for it...except for this one, The Idolm@ster Cinderella Girls U149, which was ... touted to be focusing only on the youngest of the franchise. Mainly because two other Idolmaster anime that are coming out later are going to be made in all CGI for some reason, and I have no interest in the other two that came before, the original 2011 anime and Cinderella Girls. I'm not really sure why I decided to put myself through watching U149, which is what I'll be calling this iteration, but I kinda regret doing so. There's really no denying it, U149 is just another corporate vehicle to bring in more money for a multimedia franchise.

The story itself is pretty barebones. A young producer is put in charge of the Third Entertainment Division, where he tries to help a bunch of elementary school girls debut as idols, mainly because nobody else wants to deal with them. The producer, who goes completely unnamed, as is the case for other Idolmaster properties, does what he can to help them, get to know them, and bring out their strengths and talents. If you're expecting this to be a Toddlers & Tiaras or Honey Boo Boo style show, don't worry, it doesn't stoop that low...though even in its present state, U149 doesn't really go beyond being just another generic and mediocre idol anime with cheesy, saccharine songs about making your dreams come true and twinkling and so on. A lot of its episodes are just barebones "idol girl of the week" that try to flesh out the characters to varying degrees of success. I don't know how the previous Idolmaster anime did it, but the creators' attempts at writing characters here quite plainly suck.

Seriously, I found myself much more annoyed with the idol girls than endeared, and not just because of their shrill, ear-bleeding voices screeching every single line in the most overacted ways possible. Hi again, Misaki Kuno and your nails on a chalkboard chipmunk voice. Though ironically, Kuno's character isn't even the worst one in this show. The kids constantly complain about the producer treating them like kids, with Arisu and Risa being the biggest offenders, but they continually act like selfish brats, so what right do they have to demand to be waited on hand and foot? The writers for this anime cannot write kids, because they either act too mature for their age or way too childish to the point where they behave more like toddlers than school-aged kids. The worst offenders of this are Risa and Koharu, with Risa in particular being absolutely repugnant in that not only does she threaten to accuse the producer of being a pedo at one point for an extremely petty reason, the creators decided to make her have a really, really creepy obsession with her father. And by that I mean Yuri Briar levels of obsession. Like, Risa flat-out says that she wants to become Prime Minister for the sole reason of changing the laws so kids can marry their fathers, which is what she wants to do with her own father. The fuck?! I'm not the only one who sees what's wrong with this whole thing, right? Koharu isn't anywhere near as bratty, but her problem is that in her focus episode, the whole conflict starts because she wandered away from her job and got lost...all because she let her imagination get away from her, like a toddler who saw a butterfly and wandered away from her parents. Seriously, Koharu is so annoyingly, cloyingly saccharine and sweet, her songs included, that she acts like a toddler who hasn't gotten over her Disney princess phase. She may as well have come straight out of the G3 My Little Pony Newborn Cuties specials. None of the other characters develop beyond their main archetype because the creators think having cute girls be moe is better than actually making them three-dimensional and relatable human beings.

The writing in and of itself also doesn't really make an effort to do the characters or the story justice, and often times, the show never seemed to know what it wanted to do with itself. In one episode, Momoka is called in to do a segment on bungee jumping, and everyone expects her to be scared when doing said bungee jumping, thinking that's her true self, but Momoka goes through with the bungee jump in her usual prim and proper manner...and for some reason, at the end, she goes on a diatribe about now realizing what love is. The hell?! Where did that come from?! It was completely out of nowhere, didn't fit with the rest of the episode, and I had to question just what the writers for that episode were even going for. There are also several conflicts that are unnecessarily dragged out to fill out the episode when they could have easily been resolved in five minutes if the characters just...y'know, talked things out. The show's attempts at writing drama come off as extremely shallow because it wants us to care about these kids, but what little they show of their backgrounds and motivations don't do anything to really make them anything more than, yet again, rote moe archetypes. Considering the anime juggles a large cast in 12 episodes, it doesn't have the wiggle room to really flesh out the characters as much as it could have if it had 24-26 episodes, like previous Idolmaster series had. Though...it kinda says a lot that my two favorite characters, and the ones who wound up having the best episodes, are Haru and Chie. And I gotta say, I am SO happy that Haru's episode didn't pull a 22/7 and force her to wear a skirt when she's stated she really doesn't like doing so and offered a solution that respected her autonomy. Seriously, if that episode tried to pull the whole "Tomboys have to wear skirts and be more feminine if they want to be accepted" moral, I would have thrown a shit-fit on the level of Soraya Montenegro.

I don't have as much to say about the soundtrack, as its your typical stock idol fare, with saccharine songs with shrill voices that have the same cookie-cutter lyrics. Honestly, the only characters whose insert songs didn't make me want to claw my ears out were Momoka, Chie, and Arisu. Even the background music was just completely unmemorable to me whatsoever. I mean, it's not like I could really pay attention to it over the girls' shrill, squeaky voices. The only thing about this anime I can really praise is the animation, as it's pretty good and fluid and whatever bad CGI models they use are used pretty sparingly. Though I honestly have to question why they'd use CGI models at all, as there are plenty of scenes with the girls dancing drawn in 2D, and those look way better than the 3D CGI dancing they use for some concert scenes. But the mostly good animation cannot save a terribly executed premise.

So I honestly have to ask...was this spin-off entirely necessary? What is it even supposed to accomplish? What's the point of making an anime about the youngest of the franchise if you don't even give a damn about doing anything with it? A lot of the series is just the producer trying to find work for the girls, resulting in a lot of putzing around. Which makes me realize that U149 was basically made just to rake in more money for the franchise. Yes, I know U149 started off as a manga, but the manga itself is another facet of the multimedia franchise as a whole, and U149 is just a cynical corporate product meant to both garner more brand synergy and pander to people who want to see insufferable lolis. So yeah, Idolmaster U149 is insufferable, lazy, has no idea what it wants to do with itself, and thinks shilling cutesy-poo moe girls is a good replacement for actual substance. If you're into watching this kind of stuff, you do you, but if you can't stand watching little kids screaming about how awesome idols are and the overall saccharineness of trying to shill the idol industry as being nicer than it actually is, give it a miss. You're not missing much.

Reviewer’s Rating: 5

What did you think of this review?

Nice 0

Love it 0

Funny 0

Confusing 0

Informative 0

Well-written 0

Creative 0

More reviews by Firechick12012 (301)

Show all

Read more

Show less

Open

Gift

Report

Immediate PTW

by IdolActivities

26 Entries · 10 Restacks

2020's Essentials Part 2 [2022-2023]

by baby_minu

40 Entries · 19 Restacks

Happy Lolis, No Romance

by DEMOLISH_ZIONISM

50 Entries · 163 Restacks

Recommendations

Spring 2023 Simulcast List [Update 5/19]

In this thread, you'll find a comprehensive list of television anime acquired for simulcast release during the Spring 2023 season. Anime series licensed for hom...read more

Mar 29, 2023 5:59 AM by Discuss (60 comments)

Spring 2023 Preview

In this thread, you'll find a comprehensive list of Spring 2023 titles with an accompanying promotional video, commercial, teaser, or trailer. This post will be...read more

Mar 22, 2023 2:20 PM by Discuss (12 comments)

	Poll: BonBonToro - Apr 12, 2023	55 replies	by »» May 22, 6:23 PM
	Poll: BonBonToro - Apr 5, 2023	81 replies	by »» May 22, 5:51 PM
	Poll: BonBonToro - Apr 19, 2023	36 replies	by »» Feb 5, 5:47 AM
	Poll: BonBonToro - Jun 28, 2023	40 replies	by »» Oct 31, 2024 2:34 PM
	Poll: BonBonToro - Jun 21, 2023	30 replies	by »» Jul 15, 2024 2:47 PM